End the turtle race

How the EU can address the crisis of the accession process

North Macedonia has been blocked on its accession path for more than a decade. It is no outlier. All Western Balkan states are stuck. Their accession process resembles a bus without wheels, with North Macedonia discussing conditions for moving up a row of seats inside a vehicle going nowhere. It is time for the EU to enhance the process by offering all European democracies membership in the European Single Market as a credible interim goal.

North Macedonia has been blocked on its accession path for more than a decade. It is no outlier. All Western Balkan states are stuck. Their accession process resembles a bus without wheels, with North Macedonia discussing conditions for moving up…

What to do Newsletter 6/2022 Elephants in Skopje – Balkan turtle race and Ukraine15 July 2022ReportThe Balkan Turtle Race – A warning for Ukraine13 July 2022Frankfurter Allgemeine ZeitungDas europäische Schildkrötenrennen16 July 2022Balkan InsightEU Has Turned Enlargement into a Hamster Wheel21 January 2020ReportVladimir and Estragon in Skopje - A fictional conversation o…17 July 2014

Why Russia had to be expelled from the Council of Europe

Europe’s club of democracies needs to protect itself from countries blatantly violating its rules

The Council of Europe has to protect itself from the subversive influence of member states who openly disrespect the most fundamental principles of the Council of Europe, invade a fellow member state, committing massive war-crimes, while suppressing the human rights of its own citizens. The decision to expulse Russia, for which ESI has intensively advocated for, was the only viable option, setting the basis for a strengthened Council of Europe to emerge in the future.

The Council of Europe has to protect itself from the subversive influence of member states who openly disrespect the most fundamental principles of the Council of Europe, invade a fellow member state, committing massive war-crimes, while…

What to do Newsletter 2/2022 Expelling Oceania – The Council of Europe and Russian aggres…9 March 2022 Newsletter 1/2022 Suspend Russia! The Council of Europe and the new cold war23 February 2022Report“As simple as it is appalling.” The Navalny debate highlight…22 April 2021 Newsletter 3/2021 Navalny's life – the choice in Strasbourg20 April 2021John DalhuisenWhat is the Council of Europe for?29 June 2019

Offer the four freedoms to the Balkans, Ukraine, and Moldova

For a merit-based EU accession process with a credible goal

The EU should offer membership in the Single Market, including the four freedoms, as a credible and reachable interim goal to Ukraine, Moldova, and any of the six Western Balkan nations interested in it.

The EU should offer membership in the Single Market, including the four freedoms, as a credible and reachable interim goal to Ukraine, Moldova, and any of the six Western Balkan nations interested in it.

What to doReportThe Balkan Turtle Race – A warning for Ukraine13 July 2022 Newsletter 5/2022 Ukraine, Europe and a second Treaty of Rome16 June 2022 Newsletter 1/2020 Hamster in the Wheel – Credibility and EU Balkan policy16 January 2020Balkan InsightEU Has Turned Enlargement into a Hamster Wheel21 January 2020 Newsletter 6/2019 Coup de grâce – Delors and squaring the circle – Norway in t…26 October 2019

An airlift 2022 for Ukrainians

And a European plan to help refugees in Moldova

Europe has not yet understood that Ukrainian refugees are part of Putin's plan of attack. What an answer to the millions of refugees could look like.

Europe has not yet understood that Ukrainian refugees are part of Putin's plan of attack. What an answer to the millions of refugees could look like.

What to do Newsletter 3/2022 An urgent airlift for Ukrainian refugees – how Putin’s cynic…22 March 2022The Washington PostEurope rewrote its migrant playbook for Ukrainian refugees.…19 March 2022Die Welt„Es ist besser, sich jetzt auf das schlimmste Szenario einzu…13 March 2022Los Angeles Times Ukrainian refugees in Berlin: ‘I feel guilty being in safety…11 March 2022Swissinfo.ch"Время пустых фраз прошло"8 March 2022

47 again? Russia out, Kosovo in

Support Kosovo’s membership in the Council of Europe

Kosovo’s application to become a member of Europe’s oldest Human Rights organisation is a moment of truth for many European countries which have long claimed to support Kosovo’s European aspirations. 

Kosovo’s application to become a member of Europe’s oldest Human Rights organisation is a moment of truth for many European countries which have long claimed to support Kosovo’s European aspirations. 

What to do Newsletter 4/2022 47 again? Russia out, Kosovo in16 May 2022KlanKosovaGerald Knaus and Kristof Bender: 47 shtete përsëri në Këshil…16 May 2022EurActivSerbia reacts strongly to Kosovo Council of Europe applicati…12 May 2022Exit NewsGermany Supports Kosovo Membership to Council of Europe4 May 2022Albanian PostBender e Rohac flasin për Albanian Post: Çfarë do të ndodhë…4 May 2022

Caviar Diplomacy

Why every European should care

Azerbaijan’s “Caviar Diplomacy” of systematic bribing to downplay Azerbaijan’s human rights record has led to investigations and convictions in several EU member states. So far, however, the main culprit has escaped unscathed. It is time that the Committee of Ministers investigate Azerbaijan’s role in the biggest corruption scandal in the history of the Council of Europe.

Azerbaijan’s “Caviar Diplomacy” of systematic bribing to downplay Azerbaijan’s human rights record has led to investigations and convictions in several EU member states. So far, however, the main culprit has escaped unscathed. It is time that the…

What to do Newsletter 2/2021 The strangest love affair – autocrats and parliamentarians,…2 April 2021Frankfurter Allgemeine ZeitungThe Azerbaijan clique: "A general atmosphere of venalit…30 March 2021Report The European Swamp (Caviar Diplomacy Part 2) – Prosecutors,…17 December 2016ReportCaviar Diplomacy - How Azerbaijan silenced the Council of Eu…24 May 2012

New presentations

ESI proposals presented in video format

Watch videos explaining our most recent proposals.

Watch videos explaining our most recent proposals.

What to doAtlantic CouncilWhat is a two-stage EU accession process for the Western Bal…9 May 2022ZDFMarkus Lanz - Der Talk vom 24. Mai 24 May 2022VIPACGerald Knaus - How Europe should deal with the Ukrainian ref…28 March 2022Atlantic CouncilCan the West Airlift Ukrainian Refugees to Safety? A Debrief…25 March 2022PersuasionHow (Not) to Save Refugees Gerald Knaus and Yascha Mounk dis…8 February 2022 News8 Jan 2021ESI presentation at expert workshop on the German EU presidency and the EU’s new Pact on Migration and Asylum​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Photo: Centre for Human Rights Erlangen - NürnbergESI’s Gerald Knaus was invited to participate in the expert workshop “A Fresh Start? Review of the German Presidency and Analysis of the EU Asylum and Migration Pact”, organised by Forced… News12 Jan 2021ESI university lecture on Europe’s inhumane bordersVideo: Universität KölnESI’s Gerald Knaus was invited to give an online lecture organised by the University of Cologne as part of its "What now? Learning from Crises!" series. He focused on the situation of refugees under the aggravated circumstances of coronavirus and explained ESI’s analysis… News27 Jan 2021ESI presentation on asylum and migration policy for the Franco-German Parliamentary Assembly​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Photo: German Federal Foreign OfficeESI’s Gerald Knaus gave a presentation to the Franco-German Parliamentary Assembly on asylum and migration, with a focus on Africa. Gerald stressed that there are not millions of Africans at the EU’s doorstep… News28 Jan 2021ESI presentation on refugees in the EU at Utrecht University​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Photo: Twitter Utrecht UniversityESI’s Gerald Knaus was invited to give a lecture at the Philosophy, Politics and Economics College of Utrecht University on Refugees in the EU. Gerald presented our analysis and policy recommendations on… News18 Feb 2021ESI at conference on the EU integration of Bosnia ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Adnan Cerimagic speaking at conference on EU-Bosnia relations. Photo: Amila Karacic ESI senior analyst Adnan Cerimagic participated in a conference titled “Strategic commitment: Role of parliaments in the process of EU integration.” The… Basic page1 May 2008The Adriatic push for Balkan enlargement (1 May 2008)Kotor - View from St. Ivan's Fortress, Montenegro Tirana - Bulevardi Deshmoret e Kombit, AlbaniaAre Montenegro and Albania leading a new Adriatic push for EU enlargement in the Balkans in the coming months?Montenegro is actively considering when to… Newsletter9 Mar 2021Slovenia, Serbia and an EU-Balkan breakthrough in 2021Towards a breakthrough in four stepsCan Slovenia produce a breakthrough, again? Reform, energy and realistic goalsAnnex and further readingThis newsletter is also available in Bosnian, Croatian, Montenegrin, or Serbian: Slovenija, Srbija i iskorak u odnosima EU i Balkana u 2021. godiniDear… Newsletter9 Mar 2021Slovenija, Srbija i iskorak u odnosima EU i Balkana u 2021. godiniPrema iskoraku u četiri korakaMože li Slovenija još jednom osigurati iskorak?Reforme, energija i realni ciljeviPrilog i Dodatni materijalDragi prijatelji ESI-a,Početkom 2020. godine ESI je objavio izvještaj o krizi procesa pristupanja EU na Balkanu: “Hrčak u točku - vjerodostojnost i EU… Basic page16 Mar 2021Proposal for a Revised EU-Turkey Statement 2.016 March 2021This document in PDF formatTürkçe için: Gözden Geçirilmiş AB-Türkiye Mutabakatı 2.0 TeklifiToday the Members of the European Council met with their Turkish counterpart to address the continuing migration and refugee challenges they face.Turkey and the European Union confirmed… News19 Mar 2021ESI moderates a workshop on reconciliation in the Western Balkans ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Adnan Cerimagic took part in a virtual workshop. Photo: Aspen GermanyESI senior analyst Adnan Cerimagic participated in an online workshop on “Supporting Reconciliation Processes in the Western Balkans” organised by the Aspen…