Crimeculture – reviewing since the dawn of crimeTime 2022-09-13 22:58:33
Description:Skip to content
Nancy Tucker, The First Day of Spring(2022) Reviewed byLee Horsley Nancy Tucker’s The First Day of Spring is the compelling,
Continue readingThe First Day of Spring
Simon Van der Velde,The Silent Brother(2022) Reviewed byLee Horsley Simon Van der Velde’sThe Silent Brotheris a powerfully written, deeply affecting
Continue readingThe Silent Brother
M. W. Craven, The Botanist (2022) Reviewed by Lee Horsley M.W. Craven’s The Botanist is a tense, gripping mystery, combining strong
Continue readingThe Botanist
New Feature: Contributions from writers and artists, discussing influences on their work and some of their favourite films and novels.
July 2022: Simon Van der Velde: My Top 5 Crime Books
July 2022: Crimeculture Interviews Jem Bloomfield about his fascinating new study, Witchcraft and Paganism in Midcentury Women’s Detective Fiction (Cambridge University Press, 2022)
June 2022: Crimeculture features an exclusive extract from Faye Snowden’s amazing new novel, A Killing Rain (Flame Tree Press, 21 June 2022)
June 2022: Crimeculture Interviews Acclaimed Cartoonist Matt Kindt on Launch of Flux House Imprint at Dark Horse Comics
May 2022: William Boyle contributes A Hypothetical Triple Feature Inspired byShoot the Moonlight Out.
New Fiction Reviews:
Nancy Tucker,The First Day of Spring(2022)
Reviewed byLee Horsley
Nancy Tucker’sThe First Day of Springis the compelling, forcefully written story of a child murderer. The shock of the first sentence – “I killed a little boy today” – takes us with great immediacy into the mind and grim life of Chrissie. Eight years old, Chrissie is socially ostracized, lonely and appallingly treated by a mother who rejects and ignores her, dragging her along on one humiliating occasion to an adoption agency in the hope that she can simply give her away. Clever and resourceful, Chrissie is able to use her abilities only to try to find small survival strategies and to get someone – anyone – to notice her.
Tucker has the courage to risk the slow, repetitive accumulation of detail in the child’s narrative – tense and moving for us as readers, but also capturing the sense of inescapable daily repetition, the countless deprivations in the life of a child who has nothing. She is wretchedly alone in her small world of ‘the streets’, in which everyone tries as far as possible to ignore her. Her only goal is often to gain entry to a house where the parents will feel compelled to offer her a little food. Facing slow starvation, she is frequently unable to think of anything other than her hunger. At home, “the kitchen cupboards had nothing inside except sugar and moths”.
For a brief time, the act of killing another child gives Chrissie a feeling of specialness. When people around her talk about the murder of the boy she repeatedly tries to hint at her secret, and the knowledge of her guilt gives her a fizzing sense of power: “I could feel everyone’s eyes on my back, and I bubbled with the power of it.”
Chrissie’s narrative alternates with that of Julia, the name that grown-up Chrissie takes. We follow her after her release from the secure unit in which she has spent the intervening years. Now herself a parent, Julia not only carries the burden of her childhood guilt but is despairingly trying to learn how to mother her four-year old daughter Molly, terrified at every turn that she is doomed to fail and that, everywhere she goes, there are “scheming social workers crouched in the shadows, waiting to wrench her out of my useless hands”.
People who were around in the 1960s and 1970s may well remember press accounts of the girl who strangled two small boys when she was 10 or 11,and may also be familiar withthe biographer Gitta Sereny’sThe Case of Mary Bell(1972). Sereny also wrote a second book, based on extensive interviews with Bell in later life, calledCries Unheard(1998).But although one assumes that thesehistoricalaccountsinfluenced Tucker’s work, her novel stands entirely on its own.The cumulative effect ofThe First Day of Spring is the creation of an unforgettably poignant and disturbing narrative voice. There is no romanticised poverty here. Instead, there is the overwhelming accumulation of inner torments – the harrowing substance of a life of desperation.
Simon Van der Velde,The Silent Brother(2022)
Reviewed byLee Horsley
Simon Van der Velde’sThe Silent Brotheris a powerfully written, deeply affecting coming of age story. It is dark, harrowing and often brutally, bone-crunchingly violent, but also throughout conveys the urgent need for loving bonds – none more important than that between Tommy Farrier and his younger brother Benjy.
When we first meet Tommy, he’s five years old, living with his little brother, his alcoholic mam and Daryl, his vicious step-dad. This first section of the novel gives us an intensely realised picture of the frightening, near-intolerable life of the young brothers, trying to cling on to one another and to the few things that give their lives meaning. When the social services step in to remove the boys from their abusive home, their mam makes them hide. In a heart-stopping scene, jammed together at the back of a large cupboard, they try desperately to be quiet:
“… he clings to the neck of my jarmas cos he knows…I want him to stay. So I can hold him. So his fear can make me stronger. He knows that I’m only a coward pretending to be brave and that I need him, like always. So he stays. Even when the voices are booming just outside…”
Though theterrified Benjy remains completely silent, Tommy himself inadvertently makes a sound thatleads the authorities totheir hiding place.It isBenjyrather thanhimwhois discovered and dragged away,leavingTommytortured byacuteguilt throughout the novel. The family, changing their name to Boyle, moves to Newcastle to evade the attentions of the social workers:“The van stops and we’re there, where The Social won’t find us, and I’m Tommy Boyle, age five-and-a-half, and I don’t have a brother and I never did.”Even Daryl’sworstthreats, however,can’t erase Benjy’s reality, and through all of the brutality of hislateryears, Tommyholds fiercelyto the reality ofhisdeep, wordless bond with Benjy.
In the second part of the novel, a teenage Tommystruggles to find ways of survivingboth at home and in the streets.Daryl’s violence destroys what’s left of Tommy’s boyhood world:the “magic power” that his mam once seemed to have is beaten out of her, and“Now I understand that’s how real life works.”On the streets, lifeonlyseemsworkable if heaccepts what’s on offer: when he’s fifteen, Maxihands him two plastic money bags bulging with home-grown skunkandhe sets off to make the deals thatmightat leastgive him a way out ofhisabusive home.Chosenas much as anythingforhis“innocent face”,Tommy convinces himself he has the world’s easiest job:“a hundred quid a night for sitting in a posh bar and having a pint.”Willhischoice define him for his whole life or is there is any possibility of escapefrom acriminalworld that consists entirely oftreachery and savagery,“the booze and the drugs, the dodgy deals and stolen money”?Isit possible to “changewhere you’re going”and maybe even, if you do, to “change who you are”?
The Silent Brothercreates a narrative that brings readers painfully close to Tommy’s struggle. We’re compelled throughout by his sense of failing all of those closest to him, by the omnipresent threat of violence and the occasional glimmer of redemptive possibilities. Even recognising that he was “always screwed” from the moment he chose his path, he searches for a hidden inner strength that might be reclaimed. As he drives on to face his adversaries, he thinks back, “trying to get in touch with little Tommy Boyle. Not with the guilt and the blame, but with the fight. The kid that made Daryl break his finger before he’d say he didn’t have a brother.”
M. W. Craven,The Botanist(2022)
Reviewed byLee Horsley
M.W. Craven’sThe Botanistis a tense, gripping mystery, combining strong characterisation with intricate plotting. The novel plays with familiar ingredients of the classic detective story – locked rooms, mysterious poisons – but Craven brings them together with both originality and dexterity. For a start, he offers us not one but two locked room mysteries:
“We have a killer in London who warns his victims yet still gets to them, and up north someone murdered Estelle Doyle’s father and walked away from the crime scene without treading on a single fucking snowflake.”
Although the challenges set by the puzzle of death in locked rooms and by the machinations of the novel’s methodical poisoner draw on traditional devices, the plot is very much intertwined with contemporary preoccupations. Those targeted by the killer include, for example, a Pharma Bro who uses corrupt commercial practices to buy up the rights to essential medicines and media celebrities with appalling views on women and immigrants. The public face of the poisoner’s scheme is integrally related to the modern media world, within which toxic personalities can flourish, disseminating their poisonous views and profiting from others’ weakness.
The mystery is permeated by Gothic darkness, with a killer so devious and skilled that it seems impossible to protect his victims, in spite of the fact that he forewarns them of their doom. Their murders are imagined in macabre detail,as poisons insidiously invade internal organs, bringing grotesque deaths however securely the chosen victims have tried to hide themselves.
The Botanistis the fifth novel in Craven’s hugely successful Washington Poe series, which began in 2018 withThe Puppet Show, and part of our engagement with the narrative is to do with the fact that the central characters in Poe’s life are not immune from the danger. Like the earlier books,The Botanistappeals to us by a wonderful combination of gruesome crime plots with the warmth and affectionate humour of Detective Sergeant Poe’s friendships with his “dream team”. The most important relationship in the series is between the abrasive, uncompromising Poe and the sweetly guileless genius Tilly Bradshaw, a civilian analyst whose technical wizardry becomes indispensable to every investigation. But the team as a whole is integral to both the appeal and the suspense of the series:
“Anyone who knows how to read behind the headlines will know who you prefer to work with. Tilly’s Mole People, as you call them, Superintendent Nightingale—’ ‘And Estelle Doyle,’ Poe finished for her. ‘What if someone wanted to mess with the dream team. To borrow a saying from my baseball-crazy father: what if someone wanted to bench one of your star players?’”
It’s a ‘what if’ that keeps us hooked to the very end. For any of our readers who haven’t yet enjoyed Craven’s Poe and Tilly novels, we highly recommend the whole series.
See more of Crimeculture’s recent reviews below:
Gilly Macmillan,The Long Weekend
Gilly Macmillan’s The Long Weekend is a riveting novel – complex, dark and disturbing. Close friends have planned an idyllic weekend away in a remote, beautiful Northumbrian retreat. But their long weekend, it turns out, is also a ‘lost’ weekend. The landscape itself becomes impenetrably dark and dangerous as a storm approaches. Read our review of The Long Weekend.
Rachel Howzell Hall,These Toxic Things
Rachel Howzell Hall’s new stand-alone,These Toxic Things, is a suspenseful, energetic and inventive novel.The protagonist,MickieLambert,islively and intelligent – but also young and vulnerable. At the beginning of the novel, Mickie isembarking on a new project in herroleas a digtitalarchaeologist.Read our Review of These Toxic Things.
Lucy Foley,The Paris Apartment
Lucy Foley’sThe Paris Apartmentis a cleverly constructed mystery, immersive and consistently suspenseful.At its centre is an elegant Parisian apartment block, Number Twelve Rue des Amants – an aging building of many locked rooms, sinister passageways and suspiciously watchful eyes. Long-held secrets are sequestered in every corner of the building. Read our review of The Paris Apartment.
Will Dean, The Last Thing to Burn
Reading Will Dean’sThe Last Thing to Burn(2021) is an intense, claustrophobic, visceral and terrifying experience.Thanh Dao, Dean’s narrator, came with her sister to the UK, deceived by the false promise of jobs. Now she despairs of ever escaping from the cruel and implacable Lenn, who has imprisoned her on his remote pig farm for the last seven years. Read our review of The Last Thing to Burn.
Sarah Penner,The Lost Apothecary
In her debut novel,The Lost Apothecary (2021), Sarah Penner imagines an intriguing and suspenseful intersection between the eighteenth and twenty-first centuries. In 1791, we follow the murderous life of a late eighteenth-century apothecary; in our own time, we’re immersed in the historical investigations of a young woman who stumbles on a clue that kindles an overwhelming desire to understand the life of the mysterious apothecary.Read our review of The Lost Apothecary.
William Boyle, Shoot the Moonlight Out
William Boyle is wonderfully skilled in creating vivid, memorable characters. InShoot the Moonlight Out(2021), as in his earlier novels, he draws us into the encounters – whether quirky friendships, unexpected love or ill-conceived criminal transgressions – that upend the lives of those inhabiting their small corner of Brooklyn. Read our review of Shoot the Moonlight Out.
Melanie Golding, The Replacement
Part psychological thriller, part police procedural and part dark fairy tale,The Replacement(2021) continues the police procedural framework of Golding’s debut novel, the hugely successfulLittle Darlings(2020), and similarly draws on powerful folk myths… Golding’s central protagonist is the strong-willed, intuitive DS Joanna Harper, whose own life has been shaped by the disturbing fluidity of human relationships.Read our review of The Replacement.
Liz Nugent,Our Little Cruelties
InOur Little Cruelties(2020), Liz Nugent again demonstrates her extraordinary ability to bring to life characters who both repel and fascinate us. One of the most darkly noir of contemporary crime writers, she excels in the creation of tense, gripping dramas about people imprisoned in their own obsessions and their catastrophic errors of judgement.Read our review of Our Little Cruelties.
Richard Osman, The Man Who Died Twice
Richard Osman’sThe Man Who Died Twice(2021) isan ebullient and superbly entertaining take on the Golden Age detective novel.This is the second book in his ‘Thursday Murder Club’ series, which inventively updates the formula of country village atmosphere and loveable, eccentric characters. Read our review of The Man Who Died Twice.
Lisa Jewell,The Night She Disappeared
Lisa Jewell’sThe Night She Disappeared draws us in with an absorbing, beautifully crafted story that holds us in suspense throughout. As in Jewell’s other novels, our attention is compelled not only by the intricate plotting but by characters so richly created and memorable that they stay in the reader’s mind long after the final pages. Read our review of The Night She Disappeared.
Megan Abbott,The Turnout
Megan Abbott’sThe Turnoutis a mesmerising novel, wonderfully written and vividly imagined. At once brutal and delicate, it takes place in the world of a decaying, secret-laden ballet school. Some of Abbott’s most remarkable earlier crime novels have also explored, to stunning effect, the obsessive, competitive lives of teenage girls who commit themselves to intensely demanding physical disciplines – the cheerleaders ofDare Me, the gymnasts ofYou Will Know Me.Read our review of The Turnout.
Aaron Philip Clark,Under Color of Law
Aaron Philip Clark’sUnder Color of Law is a gripping, sharply observed, fast-moving journey through the dark and treacherous world of the LAPD. It is written as the first-person, present tense narrative of Detective Trevor ‘Finn’ Finnegan, a young black cop who daily confronts the kind of horrors “that strip a person bare and leave them hollow”.Read our review of Under Color of Law.
Stuart Neville, The House of Ashes (2021)
The House of Ashesis a stunning novel, brutal, disturbing and completely riveting. It’s a crime novel but also a deeply affecting ghost story, the ghosts of children appearing to those who can see them, shadowy witnesses to the violence suffered: “A deeper darkness took her for some time, her slumber haunted by broken dreams of broken children between walls and beneath floors…” Read our review of The House of Ashes.
Catriona Ward,The Last House on Needless Street (2021)
Catriona Ward’sThe Last House on Needless Street is a surreal and fascinating novel. In the opening chapters, it would seem to be about a serial killer, Ted Bannerman, hunted by Dee, a young woman who is convinced he killed her sister when she was six. Ted has locked himself away in a run down, sinister place on the edge of a forest, where memories “lie around the house, in drifts as deep as snow.” Ward’s novel very skilfully creates a dark mixture of child murder and gothic horror, drawing us into a world that is haunted, disturbing and disorienting.Read our review of The Last House on Needless Street.
Caitlin Mullen, Please See Us (2021)
Mullen’s protagonists, Lily and Clara, are very unlike one another, but both struggling to build new lives for themselves. They are brought together under the extreme pressure of violent events, desperate to work out what has been happening and terrified that they may themselves become victims. Lily reflects,“I was so tired of being afraid. And yet, it seemed that was all this summer was: learning all of the ways that dread could creep into my days.” Read our review of Please See Us.
Inga Vesper,The Long Long Afternoon(2021)
Inga Vesper’sThe Long Long Afternoonis a beautifully atmospheric and wholly absorbing crime novel, set in 1950s Santa Monica. Vesper’s title conjures up the placid, unbroken calm of a Californian idyll – a sun-drenched suburban life, where affluent housewives display their domestic accomplishments, their blue pools, their May-green lawns.But – as any reader of Chandler will suspect – we will inevitably discover that underneath this claustrophobic, carefully constructed surface there are hidden lies, transgressions and bloodstains on the kitchen floor. Read our review of The Long Long Afternoon.
Jessica Barry,Don’t Turn Around, 2021
“Wasn’t living under the constant threat of danger just a part of being a woman in this world?” Jessica Barry’sDon’t Turn Aroundis a gripping, swiftly paced female road novel. Her evocative prose propels us into the lives of two strong, determined women, thrown together on a nightmarish journey, facing dangers that neither of them anticipated. Read our review of Don’t Turn Around.
Throughout 2020, Crimeculture reviewed a selection of the outstanding crime novels we enjoyed during the lockdown.
Crimeculture’s Lockdown Favourites
Jane Harper,The Survivors, 2020
Jane Harper’sThe Survivorsis an engrossing, suspenseful novel, with strong characters and an intensely realised landscape. It takes place in the tiny, isolated Tasmanian town of Evelyn Bay, sparsely populated except during the tourist season, when holidaymakers outnumber the town’s inhabitants.
Read our review of The Survivors
Agnes Ravatn,The Seven Doors, 2020
Agnes Ravatn’s psychological thriller,The Seven Doors, is a haunting and disturbing exploration of guilt and deception – and of an obstinate determination to expose hidden truths. Ravatn’s subtle, mesmerizing prose draws us into a complex skein of family secrets.
Read our review of The Seven Doors…
Hannelore Cayre,The Godmother (2019)
Hannelore Cayre’sThe Godmother (published asLa Daronne in France) was one of the unexpected delights of this year’s reading. It began to receive widespread recognition when Cayre – a criminal lawyer as well as a screenwriter and director –won both theEuropean Crime Fiction Prizeand the Grand Prix de Littérature Policière, France’s most prestigious award for crime fiction. Read our review of The Godmother…
Read reviews of more of our Lockdown Favourites:
Gabriel Bergmoser,The Hunted
Camilla Läckberg,The Golden Cage
Louise Candlish,The Other Passenger
Dreda Say Mitchell,Spare Room
Thomas Mullen,Midnight Atlanta
Rone Tempest,The Last Western
Lucy Atkins,Magpie Lane
William Boyle,A Friend is aGift You Give Yourself
Michael Farris Smith,Blackwood
Oyinkan Braithwaite,My Sister, the Serial Killer
Adrian McKinley,The Chain
Attica Locke,Heaven, My Home
Don Winslow,The Border
S. A. Cosby,Blacktop Wasteland
This site uses functional cookies and external scripts to improve your experience.Scroll Up
This site uses functional cookies and external scripts to improve your experience. Which cookies and scripts are used and how they impact your visit is specified on the left. You may change your settings at any time. Your choices will not impact your visit.
NOTE: These settings will only apply to the browser and device you are currently using.Powered by Cookie Information
<<< Thank you for your visit >>>