Herding the Elephant A Practical Guide to ERISA and Group Benefit Plans
Time 2020-10-26 03:02:36Web Name: Herding the Elephant A Practical Guide to ERISA and Group Benefit Plans
WebSite: http://www.healthplanlaw.com
ID:94538
Keywords:
Practical,Guide,Elephant,Description:
[P]lan administrators must create written plan documents and offer members an opportunity to examine those documents to determine exactly what [their] rights and obligations are under the plan. Id. (quoting H.R. Rep. No. 93-1280, at 297 (1974), reprinted in U.S.C.C.A.N. 4639, 5077, 5078). Given the members right to examine the documents, the plan administrator must make the documents available for examination by any plan participant or beneficiary. 29 U.S.C. § 1024(b)(2).To exercise this right, members must clearly identify whatever they want to examine. Moothart v. Bell, 21 F.3d 1499, 1503 (10th Cir. 1994). Of course, no member could clearly identify a document that the plan administrator has kept secret. So ERISA s procedure for inspection of plan documents assumes notice to members. Under ERISA, courts ordinarily conduct de novo review of a plan administrator s decision to deny benefits. In Firestone Tire Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101, 115 (1989), however, the Supreme Court adopted the view that courts should use a trust analogy in interpreting plan administrator decisions. On this view, if the plan document grants discretionary authority to the plan administration, courts should apply a deferential standard, Under this standard the court must affirm the decision unless it is arbitrary and capricious. In the present case, the Court applied the deferential standard even though the plan document granted discretion to the plan administrator. Why? Because the summary plan description did not specify that discretion was reserved to the plan administrator.The Court stated that [n]otice requires the plan administrator to disclose its discretionary authority or the existence of a document with information about the discretionary authority.4 Without either form of notice, members cannot be bound by a reservation of discretionary authority inserted into some secret document locked away by the plan administrator. The dissent took issue with the holding stating that Today the majority imposes a new duty on plan administrators to notify members that undistributed, inspectable documents could affect the scope of judicial review. One simple solution would be to include the discretionary language in the plan document as well as the summary plan description. But the plaintiffs also argued that the document was not distributed, so additional steps to ensure notice to plan participants are also advisable.<<< Thank you for your visit >>>
Websites to related : Global Washington
By Zama NeffChildren in a favela in Rio de Janeiro watch as a volunteer disinfects public areas during the Covid-19 pandemic, Brazil, April 20, 2020.
LIM TECK LEE (Pte) LtdFounded in 1918 from a humble beginning, Lim Teck Lee (Pte) Ltd was incorporated as a Private Limited Company in 1953 as a wholesaler, importer and ex
Saxon Uniforms Career Apparel BlSAXON UNIFORM NETWORK, INC. PITTSBURGH, PA USA 412-273-3496 sales@saxonuniform.com Saxon Uniforms offers a variety of uniform and career apparel it
Dove Originals Trims | Cording,COVID19 Update: To help the mask-making effort, we are constantly resupplying our inventory of and prioritizing all orders for bias tape, elastic, twi
parispi.netCloudy skies. Low 48F. Winds light and variable. Updated: October 25, 2020 @ 1:23 pm Lakewood splits home games with Harrelson Intense basketball ac
Starlutz: nude celebrity starletWelcome to a database of celebrity nude and sexy scenes. Here you will find many clips you have never seen before.Mostly they are taken from films of
Childrens Literature FestivalUmmara Waheed, Program Manager Punjab | North | ICT1-A Canal Park, Gulberg II, Lahore Tel: (+92) (42) 35711107 ext 207 Fax: (+92) 42-35711109Mob: (9
Truly Fine Wine - Curated winesDue to COVID-19, we have ceased operations as of Memorial Day Weekend 2020. Questions? Call (858) 270-9463(0) Item Baja Wine SelectionsIntroducing our
Machine Translation Archive - hoCompiledby John Hutchins for the European Association for Machine Translation on behalf of the InternationalAssociation for Machine TranslationThearch
Canonlaw.info HomepageThis website provides information about the content and operation of canon law in the Catholic Church and assists canonists and other researchers to
adsHot Websites